What is the Best Frosting for a Unicorn Cake? (Complete Guide)

I’ve always believed that food is a kind of magic. Growing up, I watched my family transform the simplest ingredients into something special—whether it was a hearty stew or a birthday cake made with love (and a little bit of improvisation). Now, as the creator behind Economical Recipes, I’m still chasing that magic in the kitchen—only with a practical twist. Budget-friendly doesn’t have to mean boring!

A few months ago, I baked my very first unicorn cake for my niece’s birthday. And oh boy, let me tell you, it was both exciting and nerve-wracking. I wanted it to be colorful, whimsical, and delicious—but figuring out what is the best frosting for a unicorn cake wasn’t as simple as I thought. Some frostings looked pretty but didn’t hold their shape. Others tasted amazing but just didn’t give me those vibrant colors I was dreaming of.

After plenty of trial and error (and a few messy kitchen counters), I found the perfect balance. That’s why I put this complete guide together—to save you from the guesswork! Whether you’re aiming for smooth swirls, eye-popping colors, or melt-in-your-mouth sweetness, I’ve got you covered.

Ready to dive in? Let’s talk about why frosting plays such a huge role in making your unicorn cake truly magical!

Part 1: Introduction to Unicorn Cakes and Frosting Choices

What Makes Unicorn Cakes So Popular?

You’ve probably seen unicorn cakes everywhere. Birthday parties, baby showers, even weddings! There’s just something about the rainbow colors, golden horns, and sweet, pastel frosting that screams “celebration.” But it’s not just about looks. A unicorn cake should taste as dreamy as it looks.

The magic of a unicorn cake lies in its layers of color, creativity, and flavor. It’s like a party on a plate! But no matter how gorgeous your design is, the frosting brings it all together. That’s where the real magic happens.

Why Frosting Matters for Unicorn Cakes

So, what is the best frosting for a unicorn cake? Well, it depends on what you’re after! The frosting has to hold its shape for those picture-perfect swirls, yet still be delicious enough that people go back for seconds (or thirds!). Plus, it needs to take color well—because that vibrant unicorn mane doesn’t just happen by accident.

In short, the frosting is the glue that holds your unicorn cake together—and the finishing touch that makes it unforgettable.

Part 2: What is the Best Frosting for a Unicorn Cake?

Best Overall Frosting for a Unicorn Cake (Buttercream vs. Whipped Cream Frosting)

When it comes to what is the best frosting for a unicorn cake, buttercream takes the crown—hands down! It’s smooth, stable, and easy to pipe into those playful swirls and colorful rosettes that make a unicorn cake so magical. Plus, it holds its shape like a champ, even if your kitchen gets a little warm.

On the flip side, whipped cream frosting has its perks. It’s light, airy, and not overly sweet. But there’s a catch! Whipped cream frosting doesn’t hold up well for detailed designs or long periods outside the fridge. So, if you’re making a unicorn cake that needs to wow guests for hours, buttercream is your best bet.

Why Buttercream Frosting is Often Considered the Best Choice

If you ask professional cake decorators what is the best frosting for a unicorn cake, most will say “buttercream” without missing a beat. Why? Because it’s versatile. You can color it any shade you like—whether you want soft pastels or bold neon tones—and it stays vibrant.

Buttercream also provides a smooth canvas for fondant decorations, edible glitter, and those fun little sugar pearls. Not to mention, it tastes as good as it looks! You can whip up a classic American buttercream or try a Swiss meringue buttercream for a less-sweet, silkier finish.

Is Fondant a Good Option for Unicorn Cakes? Pros and Cons

Fondant? It’s a mixed bag. On the plus side, fondant gives you a flawless, smooth finish—perfect if you want a polished unicorn look. It’s also great for creating 3D decorations like horns, ears, and stars.

But let’s be real—fondant isn’t everyone’s favorite when it comes to taste. Some folks peel it right off! If flavor is just as important to you as appearance (and it should be!), buttercream wins again.

Part 3: Types of Frosting for Unicorn Cakes (With Pros and Cons)

American Buttercream Frosting: A Classic Unicorn Cake Choice

Ah, American buttercream. It’s the go-to for many home bakers because it’s simple and quick to make. Just butter, powdered sugar, a splash of milk or cream, and vanilla. Boom! You’ve got a sweet, fluffy frosting that pipes beautifully.

Pros? It’s easy to color, holds up well, and gives you that classic sweet flavor that kids (and adults) love. Cons? It can be a little too sweet for some palates. But if you’re after those vibrant, unicorn rainbow shades, American buttercream is your best friend.

Swiss Meringue Buttercream: Smooth and Less Sweet Option

If you’re asking yourself what is the best frosting for a unicorn cake but want something less sugary, Swiss meringue buttercream is a winner. It’s silky, less sweet than its American cousin, and feels super light on the tongue.

The downside? It’s a bit more work. You’ll need to heat egg whites and sugar to the perfect temp, then whip it into fluffy clouds before adding butter. But the payoff is worth it. It’s super smooth and pipes like a dream!

Whipped Cream Frosting: Light and Airy, but Does it Hold?

Whipped cream frosting is perfect if you’re after a light, fluffy finish. It’s less dense, which means it’s easier on the stomach after a big slice of cake. However, it’s not ideal if your unicorn cake needs lots of detail or is sitting out for hours.

It’s also tricky to get those bright unicorn colors with whipped cream since it’s so delicate. If you go this route, make sure the cake stays refrigerated until serving time.

Fondant: Perfect for Decorating but Lacking in Flavor?

Fondant is like the fondue of cake decorating—either you love it or you don’t! It’s perfect for covering a cake in a smooth finish and creating all those fun unicorn cake accessories, like horns, ears, and stars.

But here’s the catch: it’s not the most flavorful option. Many people peel it off to get to the good stuff inside. If you’re focused on flavor and want frosting that complements your cake, stick with buttercream or Swiss meringue.

Ganache: A Decadent Alternative for Unicorn Cake Decorations

Feeling fancy? Ganache might be your secret weapon. It’s rich, chocolatey, and works wonders as a drip effect on unicorn cakes. You can even color white chocolate ganache for a pastel drizzle that adds extra flair.

But ganache is heavy, so it’s best used as an accent rather than the star of the show. Combine it with buttercream for the ultimate combo of taste and texture.

Part 4: How to Color and Flavor Frosting for a Unicorn Cake

Choosing Vibrant Colors for the Unicorn Mane

When it comes to what is the best frosting for a unicorn cake, color is everything. You want those swirls to pop, right? The key is using gel-based food coloring instead of liquid. Why? Because gels are super concentrated. A tiny drop gives you bold, vibrant colors without thinning out your frosting.

Stick with bright, fun shades like electric pink, teal, violet, and sunny yellow. Don’t be afraid to blend a few colors for an ombré effect. Oh, and if you’re going for gold on the unicorn horn, a touch of edible luster dust adds that magical sparkle. Just make sure the gold dust is food-safe!

Best Food Coloring Brands: Gel vs. Liquid Colors

Gel food coloring brands like Americolor and Chefmaster are top-notch. They deliver intense color with just a small amount. Liquid food coloring, on the other hand, can mess with the texture of your buttercream, making it too runny—especially if you’re aiming for detailed piping work on your unicorn cake.

For a smooth, consistent look, always mix your colors a few hours before decorating. This gives them time to deepen and settle, which saves you from surprises later on.

Flavoring Your Frosting Without Compromising Color Quality

Adding flavor to your frosting can be a game-changer—but you’ve got to be careful. Strong flavors like peppermint or lemon can overpower the cake. Stick with classic vanilla or almond extracts for a subtle touch.

Here’s a pro tip: use clear extracts to keep those pastel shades bright. Darker extracts, like pure vanilla, can tint your frosting a little beige. That’s fine for some cakes, but for a unicorn cake? You’ll want those colors to stay crisp and clean.

Part 5: Tips for Piping and Decorating a Unicorn Cake with Frosting

Essential Piping Tips for Creating the Unicorn Mane (Wilton 1M, 21, etc.)

Now that you’ve nailed what is the best frosting for a unicorn cake, it’s time to have fun with decorating! The unicorn’s mane is where you can get creative. Swirls, stars, rosettes—you name it.

The secret? Use a mix of piping tips. A Wilton 1M is perfect for those big, gorgeous rosettes, while a Wilton 21 makes adorable stars. If you want to add ruffles or petals, a Wilton 104 is your go-to. Load each color into its own piping bag, then have a blast mixing and matching shapes on the mane.

Make sure your frosting is the right consistency. If it’s too soft, your designs will flop. If it’s too stiff, it’ll be hard to pipe. Aim for that sweet spot: smooth, fluffy, but still firm.

How to Get the Perfect Swirls and Rosettes

Creating perfect swirls is easier than you think! Hold your piping bag straight up and apply even pressure as you swirl outward. For rosettes, start from the center and work your way around in a spiral. Don’t rush it—steady hands make pretty designs.

And here’s a tip that’ll change your life: practice on a piece of parchment paper first. Once you’re happy with your swirls, transfer your skills to the cake. You can even use a toothpick to sketch out where you want each design to go!

Gold Accents and Edible Decorations for Extra Magic

Gold details are the cherry on top for unicorn cakes. Paint the horn and ears with edible gold paint or luster dust. Sprinkle edible glitter or sugar pearls on the mane for that extra sparkle.

Part 6: Common Mistakes to Avoid When Frosting a Unicorn Cake

Overworking the Frosting: How to Maintain the Right Consistency

Believe me, I get it—you want that frosting smooth as silk. But here’s the thing: over-mixing can backfire. When you overwork your buttercream, it can get too soft or even separate. Yikes! If that happens, piping those pretty rosettes becomes a struggle.

So, mix just until your frosting is light and fluffy. If it feels too loose, pop it in the fridge for 10 to 15 minutes before using. Keeping it cool helps it hold shape, especially for those detailed mane swirls.

Choosing the Wrong Colors: How to Avoid Fading or Bleeding

Color can make or break the magic of a unicorn cake. Ever notice how some bright colors fade? Or worse, bleed into each other? That’s why using gel-based colors is a must. They stay true and bold.

Also, avoid storing your unicorn cake in humid places. Moisture can cause colors to bleed, and that dreamy mane could become a muddy mess.

Proper Storage and Transportation to Preserve Decorations

Once your unicorn cake is frosted and ready, store it in a cool place—preferably the fridge. If it’s warm, the frosting can melt, and your designs might slump. No one wants a droopy unicorn!

Transporting it? Use a cake box that’s snug but not tight. It’ll keep the cake steady and prevent any mishaps during delivery.

Part 7: FAQs About Frosting a Unicorn Cake

Print